When must the train's emergency application be initiated by someone other than the engineer?

The emergency application of the train's air brakes must be initiated by someone other than the engineer specifically when life or property is in danger. This scenario prioritizes safety and the immediate response to emergencies that threaten the well-being of people or the integrity of the infrastructure and environment. In critical situations, such as when a hazard is detected on the tracks or a severe incident occurs, it is crucial that all crew members are empowered to act swiftly to mitigate risks.

The rationale behind this is to allow for a quick response not solely dependent on the engineer, who is often focused on controlling the train's operation. Enabling any crew member to initiate an emergency application ensures that safety protocols can be followed, regardless of the engineer's current actions or awareness of the situation.

This approach fosters a culture of safety and ensures that immediate action can be taken to prevent potential accidents and protect both the lives of individuals and the physical assets involved in train operations.